The smell of coal smoke still clung to my grandfather’s overcoat, years after his last run. He’d have loved this.

My initial approach to the Lionel Pennsylvania Flyer set was cautiously optimistic. After decades spent hunched over layouts, meticulously crafting scenery and wiring DCC systems, the phrase “battery-powered” in the product description usually sends shivers down my spine. But this isn’t your average kiddie train; it’s an invitation. An accessible gateway, perhaps.

The remote is a blessing, especially for younger operators. No more frantic scrambling to reach the transformer as a runaway locomotive threatens to derail on a tight curve. Controlling speed and direction with simple, intuitive buttons makes all the difference. The set features a beautifully detailed die-cast locomotive, bearing the iconic Pennsylvania Railroad markings, ready to evoke some serious nostalgia.

One detail worth noting: the included rolling stock, while charmingly designed, uses plastic trucks. Die-cast metal trucks, a standard in higher-end O gauge models, would undoubtedly enhance the set’s realism and heft. However, this is a minor gripe, easily addressed down the road. Upgrading the trucks is an option, though probably not worth the effort unless you’re really serious about the details. Plus, the plastic trucks contribute to the set’s light weight, making it easier for youngsters to manage.

Setting up took less than fifteen minutes. Snapping the track sections together was a breeze. This isn’t a hobby requiring engineering degrees and hours of painstaking assembly. If you’re a parent looking to introduce the next generation to the joys of railroading, or someone who enjoys the model train hobby but doesn’t want to dedicate a whole room to it, this is ideal.

Compared to the Lionel Polar Express set, this Pennsylvania Flyer boasts superior detailing and a more classic aesthetic. While the Polar Express is undeniably fun, it leans more towards a purely playful experience. The Pennsylvania Flyer, conversely, offers a genuine taste of the hobby with a nod toward a classic era of railroading.

The biggest hurdle for purists? The battery-power aspect, of course. However, the lack of wires and the convenience of the remote control are undeniable. And look: sometimes, it’s okay to embrace simplicity. The train runs reliably, the sound effects are surprisingly immersive, and the overall experience is genuinely satisfying.

Consider this: are you a purist, or someone who wants to introduce a child (or yourself) to the hobby in a simple, engaging way? If the latter, order this set. You won’t regret it. Just be prepared to maybe… maybe… start thinking about expanding the layout. It’s a slippery slope.